Shooting UK

ShootingUK is the complete shooting resource for the British shooting community. From shotgun licence and shotgun certificate information to gun reviews, game shooting, clay shooting and more.

EU to scrap link between farm subsidies and wildlife law?

EU to scrap link between farm subsidies and wildlife law?

Grouse moor owners are eagerly awaiting the EU's decision


By Selena Masson, Shooting Times

Sunday, 23 November 2008

Landowners may no longer be penalised through the controversial withdrawal of farm subsidies if banned pesticides used to poison birds of prey are found on their land.

Landowners may no longer be penalised through the controversial withdrawal of farm subsidies if banned pesticides used to poison birds of prey are found on their land. In a drive to simplify its rules, the European Commission wants to sever the link between money paid to landowners under the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) and laws to protect wildlife from poisoning and trapping.
At present, landowners and farmers must comply with Article 8 of the EU’s Birds Directive, which bans the use of “non-selective methods of capture or killing of birds”, including poisons, in order to be eligible for EU farm funds.
The move comes after John Dodd, owner of the Glenogil estate, in Angus, recently had a record £107,650 in CAP payments withheld by the Scottish Government after police found poisoned baits and illegal pesticides on his estate in 2006. Such penalties have been fiercely criticised, however, as subsidies have been withdrawn in some cases without criminal involvement of the landowner being proven in law.
The Scottish Government is concerned by the proposals, which will affect all of the UK, and is calling on MEPs to retain the punitive removal of subsidies. Alyn Smith MEP said: “Scotland does have a particular problem with wildlife crime, and any means at our disposal must be an option. The new Government has made great strides in tackling this thorny issue and to lose a key weapon in the armoury would be a real step backwards.”
BASC’s Dr Colin Shedden told Shooting Times that simply scrapping the current arrangement is not the solution: “BASC recognises that crosscompliance can be a useful tool in the fight against wildlife crime — the withdrawal of part of a farm or estate’s Single Farm Payment could be a most effective deterrent or penalty. However, the other side of the coin is that a farmer or landowner could be harshly punished for the illegal actions of those who were tenants or occupiers. BASC is opposed to all aspects of wildlife crime and would support the continuation of this cross-compliance requirement as long as the penalty was imposed on those convicted of the crime.”

The rest of this article appears in 20 November issue of Shooting Times.

What is YOUR opinion?

Join other ST readers in our forums to discuss your views.



Like this article? Mark this page on a social bookmarking website...



What are social bookmarking sites?



CompPrevious
FAWC scrutinises the game industry

FAWC scrutinises the game industry

New recommendations regarding the rearing of gameb...

CompNext
Sainsbury's supports the game industry

Sainsbury's supports the game industry

On the eve of BASC’s National Taste of Game W...


Guns

Yildiz 20-bore shotgun review

Yildiz 20-bore shotgun review

This shotgun from Turkish manufacturer, Yildiz, is practical 20-bore t... Read more


More in Guns...


Sporting Answers

Why is our dog regurgitating her meal?

We have a labrador bitch which has taken to vomiting directly after he... Read more


More in Sporting Answers...


News

Electronic dog collar survey

Electronic dog collar survey

A new survey aims to gather dog owners’ experiences of electronic... Read more


More in News...


Comments

Shooting Times Magazine

What's in this issue?

Don't miss this week's issue (on sale Wednesday 1st February). FREE PRIZE DRAW - it is week 3 of our great "Gun a Week" competition, see P53 for further details and how to enter! Plus, who is top dog? Paul Rawlings reports on the 2012 Cocker Spaniel Championship. Get down to your newsagents and buy your copy today!

Subscribe to magazine


Latest articles

Grousekeeper's appeal fails

Derbyshire grousekeeper has failed to have his conviction over... Read more


Paralympics: Shotgun shooting agreement

Shotgun events being scheduled at future Paralympic Games is n... Read more


More in Latest articles...


Subscribe to Shooting Times

Shooting Gazette Magazine

Save up to 31% on a subscription to Shooting Times & Country Magazine, subscribe today and perfect gift this Christmas.