Shooting UK

From guns and gundogs to the latest shooting news; the complete online network for the British shooting community.

Jan 07
  • 12:27 | 
  • posted by James Spearman | 
  • 0 comments

Is traditional stalking at risk?

Is traditional stalking at risk?

Following the Scottish Government’s publication of Section 2 of the Wildlife and Natural Environment Bill, it is hard to take a positive outlook on the future of red deer stalking in Scotland.

On 17 November, the individual responses made to the Bill were released on the Internet. Though there were some emphatic responses from organisations, landowners, gamekeepers and various other stakeholders with genuine worries, we have to ask ourselves whether the valid comments made will actually be taken into consideration. Being optimistic, there is the hope that some of the alarming suggestions made — with particular reference to close seasons, night shooting and use of vehicles for driving deer — will be shelved for the time being. However, with the weight that the Government carries, it seems inevitable that their inadequately thought-out proposals will proceed to legislation at some point in the future.

In spite of any changes that may be imposed on us by the Bill, there is certainly a case for better communication between estates. Co-operation has already shown results, with Mar Lodge, in Aberdeenshire, coming under heavy pressure from its neighbours for its continuous culling of deer since 1995. This is just one example of when deer so often are made the scapegoat. Mar Lodge, run by The National Trust for Scotland, yearns for natural regeneration, therefore deer are given the “zero tolerance” tag and the manner in which they have been exterminated is far from the romantic ideal that stalking once held. Only recently has there been the admission that poor soil is a leading factor in the failure to regenerate Caledonian pine woodland.

This is just one example of how poor deer management has drastically changed the hills of Scotland. Deer Management Groups (DMGs) meet to discuss cull numbers and address issues, but I was aware at our last meeting that several members were absent without reason. Q1 and Q2 of Section 2 of the Wildlife and Natural Environment Bill address whether sustainable deer management should remain with landowners. Whereas the majority act diligently in this area, the few who do not are going to have a detrimental effect on those around them. If the DMGs can prove competence and co-operation then it will surely banish the necessity of open seasons, night shooting or deer driving.

While recently reading extracts from J.G. Millais’ Wanderings and memories when he stalked in Perthshire in 1918, I could see few changes from 90 years ago to now. However, I fear that the changes that could take place in the next 10 years will be irreversible. Those who value traditional stalking and a future for further generations have a mammoth task to adapt to the legislation that is thrown our way in order that the hills still host the majestic deer for centuries to come. Surely the greatness of a mammal present in our country for more than 11,000 years is of national importance?

Have your say: if you have a view on a current news topic, send it, in no more than 500 words, to selena_masson@ipcmedia.com.

What is YOUR opinion?

Join other ST readers in our forums to discuss your views.



Like this article? Mark this page on a social bookmarking website...



What are social bookmarking sites?





CompPrevious
No insects means no sloes

No insects means no sloes

If you believe that the best sloe gin is consumed ...

CompNext
Vote to ban raised laying cages

Vote to ban raised laying cages

BASC supports an end to the use of raised laying c...


Comments


Shooting Times Magazine

What's in this issue?

Don't miss our partridge and duck special in this week's Shooting Times (on sale Wednesday 1st September).
Plus, how to save money on feed on your shoot and as his Labrador nears the end of her pregnancy, Tony Jackson gets ready for the new arrivals. For all this and much more get down to your newsagents today!

Subscribe to magazine

Save up to 30% on a subscription to Shooting Times & Country Magazine, subscribe today!


Latest articles

BASC submits evidence to Parliament

BASC submits evidence to Parliament

After submitting written recommendations to the HASC, BASC see... Read more


Firearms control: deadline for submissions extended

Firearms control: deadline for submissions extended

Shooting community crashes Westminster computers as deadline for firea... Read more


More in Latest articles...


Subscribe to Shooting Times

Shooting Gazette Magazine

Save up to 30% on a subscription to Shooting Times & Country Magazine, subscribe today!